November 12, 2002
In this Issue:
1) TCWN WORKING FOR YOU!: Monterey Sewage Treatment Plan
2) ACTION ALERT: TN Oil and Gas Drilling Rules and Regulations State
Study Committee Seeks Input at Public Hearing
3) ACTION ALERT: Passenger Rail in Tennessee
4) ACTION ALERT: Push For Fair Public Hearing on Proposed Uranium
Enrichment Plant!
5) NEWS: Enforcement of Environmental Laws Has Slipped, Democrats
Say
6) RESOURCE: Hot List Collecting Important Dates
7) RESOURCE: Consider The Source - A Pocket Guide to Protecting
Your Drinking Water
8) JOB ANNOUNCEMENT: Tennessee Partnership on Organizing and Public
Policy Coordinator
9) PUBLIC NOTICE: Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control
Solicits Water Quality Data
10) PUBLIC NOTICE: TDEC Public Notices for NPDES Permits
11) PUBLIC NOTICE: TDEC Public Notice for TMDL for Fecal Coliform
12) PUBLIC NOTICE: Aquatic Resource Alteration Permit (ARAP) Notices
1) TCWN WORKING FOR YOUR!: Monterey Sewage Treatment Plan
[This is a new feature to enews. We will provide you with a short
update on our program work and to keep you informed about how we
are working for you and the protection of your watersheds.]
As part of TCWN's enforcement campaign, we are tracking a Sewage
Treatment Plan in Monterey, TN.
This facility discharges into the Falling Water River. A recent
dye tracing study, however, determined that effluent is also reaching
the Calf Killer River through a series of underground caves. This
potentially threatens the groundwater all throughout the Calfkiller
Valley. Of equal concern is that this facility has had an egregious
number of violations over the past five years mostly for dumping
untreated sewage directly into the local waterways. The NPDES permit
for this facility is currently up for review by the state and TCWN
is participating in the public process, researching the facility's
history, conducted a short and will work to ensure this facility
complies with the Clean Water such that all measures are taken to
protect the two rivers and cave systems from water pollution.
For more information about TCWN's work, to become a member, or
volunteer please visit our web-site www.tcwn.org.
2) ACTION ALERT: TN Oil and Gas Drilling Rules and Regulations State
Study Committee Seeks Input at Public Hearing
The Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC)
announced today the beginning of a public comment period and a public
hearing opportunity concerning a state study committee review of
Tennessee's oil and gas drilling regulations and laws. Citizens
are invited to critique current policy, submit proposals or offer
changes and recommendations for improving Tennessee's oil and gas
regulations to better protect Tennessee's natural environment and
economy.
An informal open house and public hearing will be held at Central
High School in Wartburg, Tennessee, located at the junction of Highway
62 and 27, on Tuesday, December 3, 2002. Public comments will be
accepted through December 6, 2002.
The open house will begin at 5:00 p.m. to allow citizens to review
current proposals, talk informally with state officials, ask questions
and share feedback. A more formal public hearing will be held from
7:00 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. where citizens can hear a brief presentation
on potential proposals to improve state oil and gas policy or regulations.
The public hearing will also include an open forum where citizens
can make statements and offer feedback on the record.
A runaway oil well and explosion in Morgan County resulted in an
oil spill in a tributary near the boundary of the Obed National
Wild and Scenic River National Park. The Big South Fork National
Park and Recreation Area is also located in the same region. The
spill was believed to be the result of an unusual geologic condition
where oil was trapped under the earth at very high pressures. When
the oil deposit was tapped by drilling, these high pressures were
transferred to the surface and overwhelmed the oil well and drilling
rig, thereby resulting in the spill.
In the aftermath of the spill, Deputy to the Governor for Policy
Justin P. Wilson requested the two primary state agencies charged
with environmental protection and economic development to conduct
a review of current oil and gas policy and regulations.
"We need the public's assistance and input to ensure that
we are doing everything within reason to protect our most precious
natural resources," said TDEC Commissioner Milton H. Hamilton,
Jr. Tony Grande, Commissioner of the Department of Economic and
Community Development added that "ideas and proposals are welcomed
and needed to help the oil and gas industry operate safely and successfully
in Tennessee."
Additional information on the public meetings, meeting directions,
current proposals and comments can be sent to www.tdec.net/epo/oilandgaspolicy/index.html,
fax to 615-532-0120 or mail to Dodd Galbreath, TDEC Policy Office,
401 Church Street, 21st Floor, L&C Tower, Nashville, TN, 37243.
3) ACTION ALERT: Passenger Rail in Tennessee
Next week, Tennesseans have a wonderful opportunity to help bring
passenger rail to our state and to take hundreds of thousands of
big rigs off our highways every year (as many as 350,000 according
to TDOT).
TDOT will hold public meetings in Memphis, Nashville, and Knoxville
to hear your thoughts on its recent rail study. In case you haven't
heard, two years ago Congress mandated that TDOT study the feasibility
of bringing passenger rail to Tennessee. Lo and behold, TDOT's Division
of Public Transportation, Water and Rail discovered that it is indeed
feasible, and it would save more than a billion dollars compared
to adding more lanes to our interstate highways. Conveniently, most
of the rail lines already exist.
This is our chance to get involved proactively. WE NEED TO PACK
THE HOUSEs! Let's show TDOT loud and clear that we want and need
passenger rail in Tennessee.
All meetings run from 6 to 8:30pm
Memphis: November 12 in meeting room C of the Memphis/Shelby County
Public Library, 3030 Poplar St
Nashville: November 13 in the Metro Nashville Howard Office Building
Auditorium
Knoxville: November 14 in the small assembly room of the City/County
building
Call TDOT at (615) 741 2781 for more information
4) ACTION ALERT: Push For Fair Public Hearing on Proposed Uranium
Enrichment Plant!
You may remember that in the late 1990's, citizen intervenors successfully
stopped Louisiana Energy Services from building a uranium enrichment
plant in a rural African-American community near Homer, Louisiana.
Well, LES is back, in a new and more virulent form. In January,
LES plans to apply for an NRC license to build and operate a new
uranium enrichment plant in Hartsville, Tennessee.
In order to avoid the outcome of their first licensing case, LES
has asked the NRC to grease the skids by pre-judging, in LES's favor.
The key issues on which the intervenors succeeded or did significant
damage in the previous case-environmental justice, financial qualifications,
and need for the facility-plus a few other issues that are problematic
for LES, such as antitrust and foreign ownership. LES has sent the
NRC six flimsy "white papers" that encourage the NRC to
decide in LES's favor on all of these issues.
The NRC should have laughed at LES's inappropriate request that
it make a "binding" pre-hearing decision on key licensing
issues, and tossed LES's white papers in the circular file. But
the NRC is taking LES seriously. The NRC has published the white
papers in the Federal Register and asked for public comment by November
13. See 67 Fed. Reg. 61932-61933 (October 2, 2002).
If the NRC lets LES hijack the hearing process, citizens will not
get a hearing on the LES plant (or if a hearing is held, it won't
mean anything as the real decisions will have already been made
via the "white papers") This will set a terrible precedent
for all future NRC licensing cases. Your comments on the travesty-in-the-making
are urgently needed.
Major issues to cover:
A. There are only two ways the NRC can make decisions that bind
interested members of the public: through the hearing process, or
through rulemakings. This Federal Register notice does not comply
with NRC procedures or basic concepts of fairness for either a hearing
or a rulemaking.
B. The white papers are totally inadequate to resolve the issues
they address. The only fair way these six issues can be addressed
is through the licensing process. If the NRC decides that it can
resolve them through a rulemaking, then it should propose a specific
resolution of the issues and explain why it is not necessary to
use the hearing process to get at the specific facts of the case.
C. The publication of the white papers raises serious questions
about whether the NRC can act as a dispassionate appellate judge
in any licensing case involving the proposed LES plant. The NRC
appears to be going along with a LES proposal that it pre-judge
every significant issue in the licensing case. How can an agency
that departs from its own well-established procedures, for the purpose
of pre-judging virtually all the important issues in a case, be
considered to be objective as the ultimate appellate tribunal in
the case?
Send your comments to: Michael Lesar, Chief, Rules Review and Directives
Branch, Division of Administration Services, Office of Administration,
US NRC, Washington DC 20555. Please send a copy of your comments
to NIRS, 1424 16th Street NW, #404, Washington, DC 20036.
For more background information on LES and these issues, check
NIRS website, www.nirs.org. There you'll find a four-page factsheet,
a press release and a background sheet on the LES "white papers."
5) NEWS: Enforcement of Environmental Laws Has Slipped, Democrats
Say
By KATHARINE Q. SEELYE
Congressional Democrats, trying to revive the issue of the environment
in a political atmosphere increasingly devoted to war, said today
that the Bush administration had fallen down on enforcing the nation's
environmental laws.
In a report to be released on Tuesday, the Democrats found a "dramatic
decline" in enforcement of environmental statutes during the
Bush administration compared with the Clinton administration based
on analyses of data from the Environmental Protection Agency.
The Bush administration initiated about half the number of administrative
actions against polluting companies in two time periods compared
with the agency under President Bill Clinton, the report said.
The agency disputed the report, saying the number for the Clinton
administration was inflated because of a new rule on drinking water
coming into effect.
The report comes five weeks before the Nov. 5 elections, at a time
when Democrats have expressed frustration over the Republicans'
monopolizing the public's attention on a possible war with Iraq.
Polls show that voters trust Republicans more on issues of national
defense, while they favor Democrats on
domestic issues like the environment. But it is not clear that the
Democrats can gain traction on these issues.
The report said the total amount of penalties and remedies recovered
from administrative enforcement actions was much less under Mr.
Bush than under Mr. Clinton. From Jan. 20, 2001, to March 7, 2002,
the Bush administration recovered $165 million from polluters, compared
with $845 million recovered by the Clinton administration from Dec.
4, 1999, to Jan. 19, 2001.
The report also compared the actions taken by both administrations
in a three-month period, from April 20, 2000, to July 20, 2000,
under President Clinton and from April 20, 2001, to July 20, 2001,
under President Bush. In those periods, the Bush administration
recovered $53 million while the Clinton administration recovered
$289 million.
Similarly, the report said, the average settlement with each polluter
during the Bush administration has been about 37 percent of that
in the Clinton administration, an average of $85,000 during the
three-month period under President Bush and $226,000 under President
Clinton.
Joe Martyak, a spokesman for the Environmental Protection Agency,
said the report was misleading for several reasons.
He said the Clinton agency took more administrative actions because
of a new rule in 2000 requiring the agency to make sure utilities
were notifying consumers of the contents of their drinking water.
"The number of administrative actions jumped, but not because
they were enforcing the same laws better,"
Mr. Martyak said. "They had another law to enforce."
6) RESOURCE: Hot List Collecting Important Dates
We are collecting a list of important dates of significant environmental
and conservation events in 2003 for our next issue of the Hot List
which will be issued in mid January.
The Hot List is being updated to provide the most up-to-date information
possible to the incoming administration team. The goal is to identify
any major environmental or conservation event in 2003 that are date
sensitive. Please provide one or more event and its action date
that is pertinent to your work. A catalogue of key events will be
published in the Hot List and distributed to its readership.
Submissions can include events, notable meetings in state or out
of state, public comment periods, NEPA document review periods,
grant or major project deadlines, state, federal or private report
releases, major study releases, key anniversaries of legislation,
state or national celebrations or other significant environmental
or conservation events.
Your assistance and cooperation will be greatly appreciated.
7) RESOURCE: Consider The Source - A Pocket Guide to Protecting
Your Drinking Water
Third in a series of outreach and assistance publications, this
Pocket Guide includes a discussion of the Clean Water Act and Safe
Drinking Water Act regulatory and voluntary resources, tools, management
measures, and finances sources available to States, local governments,
and consumers. The guide also provides information on the integration
efforts of the Underground Injection Control program with the Source
Water Protection program. For further information please contact
Kevin McCormack at
202-564-3890 or Sherri Umansky at 202-564-4639.
8) JOB ANNOUNCEMENT: Tennessee Partnership on Organizing and Public
Policy Coordinator
The Tennessee Partnership on Organizing and Public Policy (TPOPP)
is a four-year old collaboration of nine organizing and public policy
groups working together to develop a long-term strategy for achieving
significant social, economic and environmental justice on the state
level. Begun in the fall of 1998, TPOPP is currently working on
state issues related to healthcare, welfare reform, and tax reform.
Position description:
The TPOPP coordinator will be supervised by a five-member steering
committee that is ultimately responsible to the Governing Body,
comprised of members from each of the nine member organizations.
All responsibilities of the position are carried out working closely
with the steering committee.
Major responsibilities include:
1. Staffing the governing body and steering committee meetings.
2. Facilitating communication among the nine partners and our allies.
3. Developing tools to help member groups better understand and
respond to the state issues the Governing Body decides to work on.
4. Coordinating convenings, strategy sessions and other gatherings.
5. Working with others to develop tools that allow member groups
and allies to become more capable of influencing state public policy.
6. Providing administrative oversight of the TPOPP office, including
communicating with the partnership's fiscal sponsor and managing
TPOPP grants and records.
7. Coordinating contracted services.
8. Fundraising, including grant and report writing.
Salary and benefits
The coordinator position may be full or part time, depending on
workplan developments and applicants. Starting annual salary at
$31,500 (full time). Employer-paid health, unemployment, and worker's
compensation insurance, retirement benefits. Generous vacation and
other benefits. Use of staff car. Office location to be determined.
Applications
Women, working-class people, and people of color are encouraged
to apply.
Send cover letter and resume to TPOPP, P.O. Box 1364 Columbia, TN
38402 or fax: 931-380-2390
Applications must be received at TPOPP by Monday, December 2, 2002.
9) PUBLIC NOTICE: Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control
Solicits Water Quality Data
The Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control is soliciting
data for the purposes of developing the state's 2002 303(d) list
of impaired waters. Section 303(d) of the federal Clean Water Act
(CWA) requires the development of a list of Tennessee streams not
currently meeting state water quality standards that would benefit
from the development of a site-specific study called a Total Maximum
Daily Load (TMDL) and the implementation of a pollution control
strategy. This compilation, called the 303(d) List, is
subject to review and approval by the United States Environmental
Protection Agency. The 1998 version of the 303(d) List may be downloaded
from the Department's Home Page at www.state.tn.us/environment/water.htm.
10) PUBLIC NOTICES: TDEC Public Notices for NPDES Permits
The Tennessee Division of Water Pollution Control proposes to issue,
reissue, deny or terminate National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
(NPDES) permits as listed below. These permits authorize and regulate
discharges of treated wastewater and storm water from mining and
processing facilities, including access roads and haul roads located
within the affected areas. For more details visit www.state.tn.us/environment/new.htm.
ASARCO, Inc. 2421 Old Andrew Johnson Hwy., Strawberry Plains, TN
37871. Young Mill, NPDES Permit TN0027677. The existing sphalerite
(zinc) ore milling facility discharges treated wastewater and storm
water to Beaver Creek in Jefferson County. The applicant is requesting
permit renewal based on currently approved plans.
Campbell Co. Highway Dept., PO Box 19, Jacksboro, TN 37757. Area
1, NPDES Permit TN0063606. This existing limestone quarry and processing
facility, discharges treated wastewater and storm water into Cuckle
Creek in Campbell Co. The applicant is requesting permit renewal
based on currently approved palns.
Big Fork Mining Co., PO Box 727, Dunlap, TN 37327. Area 15, NPDES
Permit TN0071480, OM-71480-97-15. This existing shale mine discharges
treated wastewater and storm water into North Suck Creek and South
Suck Creek in Marion Co. The applicant is adding seven acres and
one discharge monitoring point to the permit.
Tennessee Mining, Inc., PO Box 465, Jacksboro, TN 37757. SRS Surface
Mine, NPDES Permit TN0076198, SMCRA Permit 3066. This proposed coal
surface mine discharges treated wastewater and storm water into
Hundred Acre Hollow and Prudential Hollow in Morgan Co. Applicants
for NPDES permits will discharge to surface waters which may be
classified for navigation, domestic water supply, industrial water
supply, fish and aquatic life, recreation, irrigation, or livestock
watering, and wildlife.
11) PUBLIC NOTICE: TDEC Public Notice for TMDL for Fecal Coliform
Public Notice of Availability of Proposed Total Maximum Daily Load
for Fecal Coliform in Wolf River (Mouth to Fletcher Cr.), Wolf River
(Fletcher Cr. to Germantown Rd.), Fletcher Creek, Cypress Creek,
Grissum Creek, Wolf River Watershed.
Announcement is hereby given of the availability of Tennessee's
proposed Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDLs) for fecal coliform in
the Wolf River watershed located in western Tennessee. Section 303(d)
of the Clean Water Act requires states to develop TMDLs for waters
on their impaired waters list. TMDLs must determine the allowable
pollutant load that the water can assimilate, allocate that load
among the various point and nonpoint sources, include a margin of
safety, and address seasonality.
Fletcher Creek, Cypress Creek, Grissum Creek, and two segments
of the Wolf River (mouth to Fletcher Cr. and Fletcher Cr. to Germantown
Road) are listed on Tennessee's final 1998 303(d) list as not supporting
designated use classifications due, in part, to pathogens associated
with urban storm water runoff, storm sewer systems, and agriculture.
The TMDLs utilize Tennessee's general water quality criteria, USGS
continuous record station flow data, in-stream water quality monitoring
data, a calibrated dynamic water quality model, and an appropriate
Margin of Safety (MOS) to establish allowable loadings of fecal
coliform which will result in reduced in-stream concentrations and
the attainment of water quality standards. The TMDLs require reductions
in in-stream fecal coliform loading of approximately 51% to 88%
in the four listed waterbodies.
The proposed fecal coliform TMDLs may be downloaded from the Department
of Environment and Conservation website: http://www.state.tn.us/environment/wpc/tmdl.htm
Technical questions regarding this TMDL should be directed to the
following members of the Division of Water PollutionControl staff:
Bruce R. Evans, P.E., Watershed Management Section, Telephone: 615-532-0668
Sherry H. Wang, Ph.D., Watershed Management Section, Telephone:
615-532-0656
Persons wishing to comment on the TMDLs are invited to submit their
comments in writing no later than December 16, 2002 to:
Division of Water Pollution Control
Watershed Management Section
6th Floor, L & C Annex
401 Church Street
Nashville, TN 37243-1534
12) PUBLIC NOTICE: Aquatic Resource Alteration Permit (ARAP) Notices
The following is a list of current public notices of permitting
decisions, public hearings, and rule-making activities. Public comment
and participation are encouraged on all of these issues. Comments
on any issue are welcome at any time and may be made by sending
e-mail to [email protected]
NRS 02.368 TDOT, Mountain Creek/Stringer's Branch, Hardin County,
proposed widening of SR-8 (Signal Mountain Blvd/Rd).
NRS 02.317 TDOT, Fourth Creek, Knox County, proposed widening of
I-40/75 -culvert extensions.
NRS 02.320 TDOT, Plumb Creek, Knox County, proposed widening of
Middlebrook Pike.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you for subscribing to Tennessee Clean Water Network's electronic
newsletter, Clean Water News. Tennessee Clean Water Network is a
state-wide organization whose mission is to protect, restore, and
enhance Tennessee's waters and the communities that depend on them.
We rely on donations from our membership to keep our work going.
If you value the information that Clean Water News provides please
consider becoming a member of TCWN. Visit our web-site at www.tcwn.org
for more information
|